In a recent thread of comments on Substack, one person tried to reframe the Holocaust not as an ideological genocide, but as a reluctant, reactive measure taken by a defeated and indifferent Nazi regime.
Here is what they wrote:
“The Germans started the Holocaust killing because they were afraid of the advancing Russians using the same prisoners as slave labor to further fuel the Soviet invasion. In their minds they had no choice… majority of those in the camps were Jews… that was Hitler’s fault after unenthusiasticly making them the scapegoat when he was actually apathetic… but the killing was a strategical choice made in defeat... The systematic killing in the German camps. It didn’t start until 1943… once the Germans started to lose the war and Hitler has already been “defeated” mentally… he lost the pep in his step and became a “whatever” man… basically signing whatever order came across his desk…”
This commentary is historically incorrect and revisionist, to say the least. You are promulgating Nazi apologia. Let me correct some of your wildly inaccurate claims:
The mass murder of Jews, Slavs, and other “undesirables” began long before 1943. Systematic mass shootings of Jews began in 1941, within weeks of the invasion of the Soviet Union. Gassing of Jews followed that same year: gas vans in the east by late 1941, and the first killing center at Chelmno in December. These atrocities were carried out by mobile killing squads (the Einsatzgruppen), along with other SS and police units and local collaborators, who murdered well over a million people. Those units were assembled and instructed before Operation Barbarossa even began, and their early orders already targeted Jews. By late summer 1941, under Himmler and Heydrich, they were wiping out entire communities: men, women, and children. This was not a 1943 improvisation in defeat. It was a racial war of annihilation from the opening weeks. By 1943, more than half of the victims of the Holocaust had already been murdered. Operation Reinhard alone, in 1942, killed well over a million Jews at Belzec, Sobibor, and Treblinka.
Ideology drove the genocide, not military panic. It is extensively documented that the Holocaust was driven by core Nazi racial ideology, not reactive military anxiety about Soviet labor pools. The regime viewed European Jews as an existential racial “threat” that had to be totally eradicated. The Nazi war machine brutally exploited some camp prisoners for forced labor, but that exploitation existed alongside the primary, systematic goal of total extermination, and was always secondary to it. The killing centers at Belzec, Sobibor, Treblinka, and Chelmno existed to murder people on arrival, not to extract work from them. Even in 1944, with the war already lost and Germany desperate for labor, the regime deported about 437,000 Jews from Hungary in a matter of weeks and murdered most of them in the gas chambers at Auschwitz on arrival.
Antisemitism was Hitler’s core mission. Eliminationist antisemitism was the central, foundational pillar of Hitler’s entire worldview from his earliest days in politics (as detailed in Mein Kampf) through the end of the regime. It was not a casual or forced political tool. It was his primary ideological mission, and he remained obsessed with it until his suicide in April 1945. The day before he killed himself, he dictated a political testament that still blamed “international Jewry” for the war and demanded merciless opposition to it. That is not the voice of a “whatever” man rubber-stamping other people’s ideas.
At best, this person is historically misguided, quite likely from listening to Tucker Carlson, who has promoted this sort of BS quite loudly. In September 2024, Carlson gave a friendly platform to Darryl Cooper, who claimed the Nazis were simply unprepared for millions of prisoners, “just threw these people into camps,” and that “millions of people ended up dead there.” That is a lie. The camps were not a logistical accident. Carlson did not challenge it. He called Cooper “the most important popular historian working in the United States today” and said he assumed Cooper’s claims were “all right.” Yad Vashem called the account historically false. Its chairman, Dani Dayan, called the performance “one of the most repugnant forms of Holocaust denial of recent years.” At worst, the commenter is actually a Nazi fellow traveler and antisemitic apologist.
The Bitter End: They Kept Killing to the Last
The notion that Hitler had become an apathetic, passive bystander simply rubber-stamping orders as a “whatever man” completely collapses against the physical reality of the war’s final years, not just its final months.
The war was already lost in 1944 when the regime deported hundreds of thousands of Hungarian Jews to Auschwitz and murdered most of them on arrival. That was not a reluctant calculation made in a panic. It was the killing machine running at full speed after Stalingrad, after D-Day, and after any rational military logic would have stopped it.
Mass gassing at Auschwitz ended in November 1944, not because Hitler had gone soft, but because Himmler ordered the gas chambers and crematoria destroyed as the Red Army closed in and the SS tried to cover its tracks. The Red Army liberated the camp on January 27, 1945, and found about 7,000 prisoners the SS had left behind. The rest had already been driven out. Starting on January 17, the SS forced tens of thousands of Auschwitz prisoners on death marches in the dead of winter, shot anyone who fell behind, and kept those marches going, from camp after camp, into May 1945. Even as the Reich came apart, the regime still found trains, guards, and fuel for the Hungarian deportations in 1944 and for the death marches in 1945. That manpower was not a gift to the front. The slaughter was pursued with fanatical, unyielding zeal to the very end.
And no, Hitler was not a passive bystander at the end. When he learned that Himmler was putting out peace feelers to the Western Allies and trying to use Jewish prisoners as bargaining chips, he was furious. He had Himmler’s liaison, Hermann Fegelein, shot, and he expelled Himmler from the party. Then, on April 29, 1945, hours before his suicide, he left a political testament that still blamed the Jews for the war and demanded that the fight against them go on.
Why This Kind of Revisionism Matters
Arguments like the one quoted above do something very specific: they attempt to divorce the perpetrators from intent. By painting Hitler as an apathetic bureaucrat and framing the genocide as a tragic military calculation, this narrative transforms deliberate mass murder into an accidental tragedy of war.
History leaves no room for this interpretation. Recognizing this history accurately isn’t just about getting dates right; it’s about holding perpetrators accountable to the truth of what they did.
Further Reading
Mass Shootings of Jews during the Holocaust (United States Holocaust Memorial Museum). The 1941 killing in the East: when it started, who carried it out, and the scale.
Death Marches (United States Holocaust Memorial Museum). The evacuations of 1944 and 1945, including the January 17 march out of Auschwitz, and the SS orders to shoot anyone who could not keep up.
Security n Cigars is reader-supported. Subscribe to get new posts and support the work.






This is an appropriate moment for your column. Anti-Israel and Jew-hatred is at a fever pitch. The only country in the middle east holding Western values and democracy is under determined attack. And israel’s “friends” are acting pretty goddamn flaky. Let’s join, shoulder to shoulder, to defend a lifelong friend and ally. ---Ross
The USA cancelled the copyright on Mein Kampf and threw it into the public domain, so nobody could profit from the book, so you can find it for free on the Internet and read it for yourself.
When people tell you who and what they are, believe them.
I used to find it amazing how the German people so quickly became so antisemitic. Looking at today, I'm not amazed anymore, at all.
Genesis 12:1-3